What we " are" as Eagle Harbor Insurance

What really is an insurance brokerage? I get asked this all the time ! I also hear folks around town say "My insurance carrier is Eagle Harbor Insurance". This question or puzzle has a clear , yet broad answer: An insurance brokerage, such as Eagle Harbor Insurance is actually an intermediary between you the client and the true insurance carrier. We as a brokerage represent YOU as our client, and we always strive to find you the best rates and coverage. We shop your coverage annually and make sure we get you the best rate and carrier currently on the market for your risk, It does not cost you ANYTHING more to use our services and truly gives you another layer of expertise advice on proper coverage. We also are not the " insurance carrier", we leave that to the carriers we represent, such as Hartford, Kemper, Guide One , Progressive, Foremost etc. We can handle claims filing , bill paying, and changes to your policy, so this is never an issue. Bottom line, why not use a broker for your insurance? It is free, gives you expert representation, and allows you access to markets you will not find in the direct market to clients. Please call us anytime for a free, complete review and risk analysis of your current policies.

"We dont sell insurance, we help people buy it"

This has always been our motto and continues.... We understand every family has different insurance needs, be it coverage or premium. No two cases are the same and we will always do our best to guide you into proper coverage to fit your budget. We are here to help ...anytime. 206 842 7410

We welcome our new agent Jenna Koehler

As of May 2013, we have hired a new agent Jenna Koehler. Jenna is a life long resident of Kitsap County and spent her entire school years here on Bainbridge Island, graduating from Bainbridge High in 1995.

Jenna's background is in banking and most recently residential real estate sales, specializing in Kitsap county single family homes. With her extensive knowledge of the Kitsap area and already large client base, she was a perfect fit for our agency and has made a very smooth transition to the insurance side of business.

We look forward to supporting her client base and having her help our agency grow.

Please feel free to reach out to Jenna for a quote and experience her excellent service.


206 842 7410

Available Monday thru Friday and weekends by appointment.


About Us

At Eagle Harbor Insurance, all things are possible.

You see, we don't think of ourselves as being in the business of selling insurance. We're really in the business of helping you buy the insurance you need to attain the life and lifestyle you want. We'll get you the right coverage for every personal, commercial and unique circumstance imaginable.

Whatever you can dream, we've got you covered.

Tom Sawyer- Broker- Owner

tom sawyer.JPGTom Sawyer has been with Eagle Harbor Insurance since 2005, and effective 1/1/2013 is now the Principal Broker and owner of Eagle Harbor Insurance! Tom is deeply embedded into the community, and being acquainted with most of the people on the island, sees people as neighbors and friends, not just clients. Tom is highly qualified in all lines of insurance and his ability to listen , along with his attention to detail ,guarantees that you will receive  insurance plans customized to meet your needs. Please do not hesitate to call and set up an appointment with Tom for a full insurance portfolio review.

Rita Riley- Agency Manager

Rita Riley has been with Eagle Harbor Insurance since October, 2007 and as of 2013 has been appointed the agency manager. She has been in the insurance industry since 1981 and has extensive experience in both personal and commercial insurance. She provides leadership and direction to our agency and has build long lasting quality relationships with vendors, producers, and clients alike, serving each of you with warm, personal, genuine service. 

Please call her anytime, no matter how simple the question!